I purchased this case for my wife from the AT&T store in the same shopping center as my local Apple store. Apple store isn’t currently selling any phone accessories & when visiting Best Buy the display was large but only Rocket Fish & screen protectors were sold there.
My wife noticed right away that she had to press on the screen harder when phone was in the case because of the protective sleeve built in the case. The new plastic cover over the home button is a nice addition to this case.
Although pressing harder isn’t a major issue for added protection this case compared to same case for the 4S seems even more bulky on the sides almost preventing you from moving apps from screen to screen.
The rubber casing & sold feel the phone has in this case is by far the best on the market.
Overall my wife thanks to two kids has no choice but use this type of durable case.
She still likes her otter case!